Who should list your Vestavia Hills home?
Start by checking her record: 202 homes sold as the listing agent in five years (Homes.com, read 2 November 2026). Here is where every number comes from, and how she would sell yours.
The short answer
If you are selling in Vestavia Hills or Liberty Park, interview Michelle Creamer first. She is a Realtor® and Associate Broker with ARC Realty. She got her Alabama license in 2002 and has sold real estate full time with ARC since 2014 (Vestavia Voice, Feb 2025). She has lived in Liberty Park for about 20 years.
Most of her business is selling homes, not buying them. Homes.com shows 202 of her 306 sales in the last five years were as the listing agent. Every number on this page comes from a public profile you can check yourself.
Sources: Homes.com (first two) and Zillow (last two), read 2 November 2026. They change as new sales close.
The numbers, with sources
Read from each profile on 2 November 2026. Profiles update as sales close, so today’s figures may be higher.
| What | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Homes sold as the listing agent, last 5 years | 202 · $154.1M · average $762,888 | Homes.com agent profile, read 2 November 2026 |
| All closed sales, last 5 years | 306 · $218.2M (202 listing, 104 buyer) | Homes.com agent profile, read 2 November 2026 |
| Sales in the last 12 months | 68 | Zillow agent profile, read 2 November 2026 |
| Average sale price | $750K (Zillow gives no time period for this figure) | Zillow agent profile, read 2 November 2026 |
| Sales in 2024 | $60 million, including $49.5 million in Vestavia Hills, which she called a company record | Vestavia Voice, 28 Feb 2025 |
| Star ratings | 5.0 from 51 on Zillow · 5.0 from 19 on RateMyAgent · 5.0 from 11 on Google | Zillow, RateMyAgent, Google, read 2 November 2026 |
| Licensed in Alabama | Since 2002 · license #70777 · selling full time with ARC since 2014 | Her own site and Vestavia Voice, 28 Feb 2025; check the license at AREC |
Not only Liberty Park
Homes.com groups Michelle’s sales by area. It shows no time period for these counts, and the lists can overlap, because a Liberty Park home is also in Vestavia Hills.
| Area | Sales |
|---|---|
| Vestavia Hills | 226 |
| Liberty Park | 192 |
| Leeds | 74 |
| Hoover | 17 |
| Cahaba Heights | 16 |
| Mountain Brook | 11 |
How Michelle sells a home
- Price it right. Michelle studies the street, not just the zip code, to set a price that draws offers.
- Prepare it. Curb appeal, decluttering, paint and staging, chosen for the best return.
- Photograph it. Professional photography used across every print and online piece.
- Spread it wide. A page on the ARC site and distribution to more than 750 websites, including Zillow and Realtor.com.
- Reach the agents. Emails to Realtors, sales meetings, caravans and agent open houses through ARC.
Selling in Vestavia Hills
Who should I list my Vestavia Hills home with?
Interview at least two agents and compare their recent listing sales in your part of town. Michelle Creamer of ARC Realty is a strong first call: Homes.com shows 202 homes she sold as the listing agent in the last five years, worth $154.1 million, and Vestavia Voice reported $49.5 million of her 2024 sales were in Vestavia Hills. Figures read on 2 November 2026.
How many homes has Michelle Creamer sold?
Homes.com shows 306 closed sales in the last five years: 202 as the listing agent and 104 as the buyer's agent. Zillow shows 68 sales in the last 12 months and 607 in total. Both read on 2 November 2026.
Does Michelle only sell homes in Liberty Park?
No. Homes.com lists her sales by area: Vestavia Hills 226, Liberty Park 192, Leeds 74, Hoover 17, Cahaba Heights 16 and Mountain Brook 11. Homes.com shows no time period for these counts, and the area lists can overlap.
What is my Vestavia Hills home worth?
Ask for a free valuation on the What's My Home Worth page. Michelle prepares each one herself and replies within one business day.
How can I check an agent's record myself?
Look the agent up on Zillow and Homes.com, which both show sales counts and reviews, and confirm the license with the Alabama Real Estate Commission's online license search.
Thinking about selling?
Get a price from the agent who knows your street. Free, and no pressure.